Plain Bird I Can't Identify

by Ithacajosh
(Ithaca, NY, USA)

I've had feeders all my life (let's just say more than fifty years). I'm in Western NY. I had a bird on my feeder that I simply cannot identify. Maybe it's a common one that I've simply never seen.


Although I don't have a pic, I can give a pretty good description. It's all charcoal gray (maybe slightly on the brown side). Slightly darker on the wings and back. Even slightly darker, toward black, on the tail. Black eyes. Finch-like beak, but very dark, almost black. Slim like a cowbird, and about the same size, but not shiny like a cowbird and without a brown head. A little bigger (and slimmer)than the slate-colored juncos I'm used to, and definitely no white or light color anywhere. Not speckled, but I think I can see some very faint stripes on wings and, perhaps, the back. About 70% as big as a red-winged blackbird.

Any ideas, anyone? Thanks!

Comments for Plain Bird I Can't Identify

Click here to add your own comments

Apr 26, 2013
Thank You! NEW
by: Ithacajosh

**Sigh**

You can tell I'm not a professional birder. Thank you for the suggestion. Now that I've looked at many pictures of female cowbirds, I believe you are right. Leave it to a boneheaded guy to ignore the female. :-)

Thanks!

Apr 26, 2013
bird ID NEW
by: AuntGiki

maybe a female cowbird

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to What Is This Bird?.



Coming Soon

Recent Articles

  1. Pink bellied black bird?

    Sep 21, 17 09:29 AM

    We had a bird about the size of a woodpecker which acted like a woodpecker on our tree two days ago. The most distinctive feature was a light pink belly.

    Read More

  2. YellowGreen Bird ID help

    Sep 08, 17 04:37 PM

    This bird is about the size of a small cardinal. I have never seen it at a feeder but it comes to the bird bath. The photo is not the best but hopefully

    Read More

  3. Paul

    Sep 03, 17 09:24 PM

    A relative went to HB class. They found it is safe and more effective to use 2 water to 1 sugar. I use 4 cups of boiling water into 2 cups sugar.

    Read More