hard to ID

by Brook
(Troutdale, OR)

Hi Pacific Northwest friends, Brook here. I have seen this bird for the second year now but only once each year. I don't have a clue. It's head and breast are bright red and this was last week, it's lower belly is a faint yellowish hue. From the back it's wings are brown and look like a female house sparrow but the markings are the same yellow as the low belly. I didn't not notice the color of the legs but the beak looked possibly finch or grosbeak or maybe not, it was larger than a house finch and smaller than a grosbeak and was at sitting on my gate. Audubon didn't know and I can't find it in Sibley's or anywhere else.

Comments for hard to ID

Click here to add your own comments

Jul 27, 2014
hard to id NEW
by: Brook

Hi Susan and Judy, as odd as it seems this has to be a large male house finch in breeding plumage. He would be gorgeous male I've ever seen if it were breeding season but I feel bad for the poor fellow. I'm fairly certain it was him that I saw through the tree branches last summer too. After extensively searching online this is the only description that is possible. Has anyone ever ran across a bird so out of season like this?

Jul 26, 2014
Red Crossbill? NEW
by: Judy-Seattle

Hi Brook! Looking in my "Birds of the Puget Sound Region" book, I think the Red Crossbill might fit your description. The book says the males' plummage is variable, "generally brick-red, sometimes orange, yellowish-brightest on the crown and rump. FEMALE:Olive-yellow." I have never seen one.

Jul 26, 2014
hard to id NEW
by: Brook

This bird was bright, bright red like the red on a Hairy Woodpecker and the red was uniform all the way down the breast. Can that fit a Purple finch?

Jul 26, 2014
Purple finch NEW
by: Susan

My first thought was a Purple Finch. Have you already crossed that off the list of possibilities.?

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to What Is This Bird?.



Coming Soon

Recent Articles

  1. nestling bird

    Dec 11, 17 07:32 PM

    he or she nestles on top of our front door in the winter months in Phoenix,AZ. It is medium to small in size. It is lighter underneath, but really not

    Read More

  2. Snowbirds!!!

    Dec 10, 17 02:02 PM

    Drinking our morning coffee my boyfriend was looking at his bird feeder and said to me wow what are those birds? I said ohhhh they are snow birds... we

    Read More

  3. Looking for positive ID of this baby bird

    Nov 30, 17 10:40 PM

    Found this one in Popler tree, there were two chicks but one died due to fall. Chick is same size as dove chick but has bright orange pen feathers sprouting

    Read More